Growing companies eventually get to a point where spreadsheets no longer cut it. To optimize their procedures and facilitate growth, they conclude that they need some software package. But which one is the best choice? Most business professionals have heard the term “ERP,” but they may not know exactly what enterprise resource planning software is or if this is exactly what they need for their company. Below we explain what ERP is, how it works, and how to choose the right solution for your business.
Table of contents:
- ERP / MRP / MES and other manufacturing software for production scheduling and control. read more →
- Why do manufacturing ERP or MRP systems not be the best idea, and Why most MRP or ERP systems fail in a small manufacturing company? read more →
- What you think You need from manufacturing ERP / software, and what You really need? or which is better to choose: ERP / MRP software for production scheduling? read more →
- Which manufacturing software or ERP system is best for small production planning and scheduling (depending on the industry you represent and your company’s size). read more →
- What are free or inexpensive alternatives to ERP / MRP, and why free ERP systems are generally costly? read more →
- Why should you avoid using offline ERP manufacturing software, and what are the best trends to consider? read more →
When you type in google search engine the phrase “manufacturing software”, you are spoilt for choice. Thousands of companies have a wide range of products and services, and after spending hours researching, you are none of the wiser. Some basic definitions should make things clearer, considering that top google positions occupy large companies selling sophisticated resource planning systems, which might not necessarily be synonymous with what you are looking for.
ERP is an acronym that stands for enterprise resource planning (ERP). It’s a business process management software that standardizes, streamlines and integrates business processes across finance, human resources, procurement, distribution, and other departments. Typically, ERP systems use an integrated software platform operating on a single database, which collects and organizes key business information that helps organizations run lean and efficient operations as they expand.
How does ERP function?
Once information is compiled in that central database, leaders gain cross-departmental visibility that empowers them to analyze various scenarios, discover process improvements and generate major efficiency gains. That translates to cost savings and better productivity as people spend less time digging for needed data.
ERP has evolved from a human resource management application to a tool that spans IT management. That’s why for many users, an ERP is a “do it all” system that performs everything from the entry of sales orders to customer service. It attempts to integrate the suppliers and customers with the manufacturing environment of the organisation.
ERP belongs to a category of business software, but its systems comprise various modules, each addressing a specific business requirement. The names and numbers of modules in an ERP system provided by various software vendors may differ. The most popular modules of ERP target:
- engineering data control (bill of materials, process plan and work centre data); sales, purchase and inventory (sales and distribution, inventory and purchase);
- material requirement planning (MRP);
- resource flow management (production scheduling, finance and human resources management);
- works documentation (work order, shop order release, material issue release and route cards for parts and assemblies);
- shop floor control and management and others like costing, maintenance management, logistics management and MIS.
Also, the modules of ERP include areas such as:
- Finance (financial accounting, treasury management, enterprise control and asset management). This lays at the basics of the ERP concept.
- Logistics (production planning, materials management, plant maintenance, quality management, project systems, sales and distribution),
- Human resources (personnel management, training and development and skills inventory),
- Workflow (integration of the entire enterprise, with flexible assignment of tasks and responsibilities to locations, positions, jobs, groups or individuals).
ERP in practice
How does it look in practice? For instance, the customer relationship management (CRM) module tracks all communications with clients, assists with lead management and can enhance customer service and boost sales. Professional services automation plan and track projects, including the time and resources spent on them. It can simplify client billing and encourage collaboration among staff members working on a project. The Working Time Management (WTM) module keeps track of attendance and hours spent at work, and in some systems, can also manage payroll. It can record absenteeism and productivity by department, team and an individual employee. The list can go on forever.
Each module pulls information from and pushes information into the central database that is a key component of an ERP system. This common data repository provides visibility into all departments. It thus allows leaders to evaluate and compare the performance of different business areas and understand the full impact of decisions.
A brief history of ERP
The ERP system traces its roots commencing from standard inventory control packages to material requirements planning (MRP) in the 1960s. Manufacturers used MRP software to plan production schedules, make sure they had all the necessary supplies for production runs and track finished inventory. It was one of the early business applications, which did not belong to the finance and accounting area. MRP at its core is a time phased order release system that schedules and releases manufacturing work orders and purchase orders, so that sub-assemblies and components arrive at the assembly station just as they are required. Some of the benefits of MRP are reduction of inventories, improved customer service, enhanced efficiency and effectiveness.
MRP evolved and expanded to include more business functions such as product costing and marketing. In the early 1980s, MRP expanded from a material planning and control system to a company-wide system capable of planning virtually all the firm’s resources. This expanded approach was MRPII. A major purpose of MRP II is to integrate primary functions (i.e. production, marketing and finance) and other functions such as personnel, engineering and purchasing into the planning process to improve the efficiency of the manufacturing enterprise.
ERP – the term is born
The Gartner Group of Stamford, the USA, coined the term ERP in the early 1970s to describe the business software system that is the latest enhancement of an MRP II system (encompasses all MRP II modules).
A key difference between MRP II and ERP is that while MRP II has traditionally focused on the planning and scheduling of internal resources, ERP strives to plan and schedule supplier resources as well, based on the dynamic customer demands and schedules.
Who uses ERP?
ERPs were originally designed for manufacturing companies but have since expanded to service industries, higher education, hospitality, health care, financial services, and government. Each industry has its own ERP peculiarities. For example, government ERP uses contract lifecycle management (CLM) rather than traditional purchasing and follows government accounting rules. Banks have back-office settlement processes to reconcile checks, credit cards, debit cards, and other instruments.
Different solutions cater to a wide variety of organizations and requirements. Industries that use ERP to run their businesses include: advertising and digital media, consulting, education, energy, media and publishing, manufacturing, food and beverage, retail, transportation and logistics, wholesale distribution and many more.
Key features of ERP systems
ERP systems typically cover all aspects of business operations and commonly provide:
- An integrated system
- Common database
- Real-time operation
- Support for all applications/components
- Common user interfaces across application/components.
- On-premise, cloud-hosted, or SaaS deployment.
ERP software has the ability to collect and compare metrics across departments and provide a number of different reports based on roles or specific user preferences. The data collected synchronizes reporting and automation by reducing the need to maintain separate databases and spreadsheets that would have to be manually merged to generate reports. This collection offers valuable insight, such as where to cut costs and streamline processes, providing the information to make real-time business decisions.
How does the ERP system work?
As companies’ needs change and they expand, their systems should keep up with this process. ERP systems work by using a defined, standard data structure. Information entered by one department is immediately available to authorized users across the business. This uniform structure helps keep everyone on the same page. For example, say a local printing shop chain has multiple locations that often share stock and personnel. As quality, sales and employee data from these sites is fed into the ERP system, it’s formatted to indicate which location it comes from.
Data is then woven into business processes and workflows across departments. Leaders can see if one location is doing significantly better than a sister site a few towns over and work to figure out why, while operations can make sure staffing levels align with traffic patterns. Finance can compare sales to rents to help executives decide whether to consolidate.
Different types of ERP systems
Various ERP models address the needs of different organizations, but there are four main types of ERP based on deployment options:
- On-Premise ERP software is implemented onsite and maintained in physical office space within an organization, hosted on the company’s own computers and servers for full control, support and ownership of the entire system once implemented.
- Cloud-based ERP software is a web-based solution, known as Software as a Service (SaaS), where an organization accesses and stores data on any device with an internet connection, usually through a subscription. The software provider ensures continual support, updates, training, and flexible customizations.
- “Hybrid” ERP software refers to a combined implementation of cloud-based and on-premise ERP system solutions. The combination of hosting and deployment services vary – some companies may turn to cloud solutions for certain business needs while sticking with their on-premises systems for other functions. Either way, the cloud systems must be linked to the on-premises platform to ensure a steady flow of information—often easier said than done.
- Open-source ERP: Like other open-source applications, open-source ERP is an inexpensive, and sometimes free, alternative that’s suitable for some companies. Many open-source ERP providers allow businesses to download their software for free and charge a low annual fee only if the customer wants cloud access. With more modern web-based interfaces and a growing number of modules, these solutions have improved, but companies need to understand what they’re taking on with an open-source ERP. Support from the provider will be minimal, and configurations and system improvements will fall on the client. That means you need technical staff with a deep knowledge of how to develop and configure the software.
ERP Systems by Business Size
No single system will be best for every small, midsize or large company, respectively. But there are features specific to these segments as well as favored deployment models.
Small-business ERP: Small firms should map out their requirements before starting a search to avoid software that has far more functionality than they need. That’s why cloud ERP is generally the best option for small businesses — it offers the scalability to meet the business’s needs as it grows.
Midsize-business ERP: Midsize companies should demand a platform that can support all its business functions with specialized modules and, like smaller firms, select a vendor capable of scaling to meet future needs.
Enterprise ERP: Enterprises should opt for software that can support different components of their businesses. Corporations require systems that can capture, process and interpret a vast amount of data and handle the demands of many business units.
Benefits of ERP Systems
Today’s ERP solutions have rich feature sets that bring countless benefits to businesses. Here are key universal advantages ERP delivers:
1. Workflow visibility: With all workflows and information in one place, employees with access to the system can see the status of projects and the performance of different business functions relevant to their jobs. This visibility may be particularly valuable to managers and leaders, and it’s far faster and easier than searching for the right documents and constantly asking colleagues for updates.
2. Reporting/analytics: Data is useful only if companies can analyze and understand it, and an ERP helps with that. Leading solutions have impressive reporting and analytics tools that allow users to not only track KPIs, but display any metrics or comparisons they can dream up. An ERP provides an audit trail by tracking the lifecycle of each transaction, including adherence to required approval workflows
3. Automation: By automating many simple, repetitive tasks, you minimize errors and the need to add employees at the same rate as business growth. Cross-company visibility makes it easier to spot inefficiencies that drive up costs and leads to better deployment of all resources, from labor to inventory to equipment.
4. Business insights/intelligence: Because ERPs can access data from across the company, these systems can uncover impactful trends and provide extensive business insights. This leads to better decision-making by organizational leaders who now have easy access to all relevant data.
5. Risk management: ERP technology reduces risk by strengthening financial controls. More-accurate data heads off mistakes that could lead to lost sales or fines.
6. Collaboration: ERP solutions make it easy to share information — like purchase orders, contracts and customer-support records — among teams.
Disadvantages of ERP Systems
Although ERP systems have certain values they have some disadvantages due to the tight integration of application modules and data. Huge storage needs, networking requirements and training overheads are frequently mentioned ERP problems and the major reasons for ERP dissatisfaction. The other shortcomings of the ERP systems include:
- High costs of this system. It is calculated that customers spend between three and seven times more money on ERP implementation and associated services compared to the purchase of the software license or some simple cloud-based manufacturing software solution. ERPs require a time and financial investment hence the technology is much more affordable to larger enterprises. High cost prevents small businesses from setting up an ERP system.
- Specialized training. Lack of trained people may affect ERP’s efficiency. The ERP’s functionality depends on proper training and many of the staff might be resistant to that. An ERP system is loaded with features, and that can be daunting to your workforce. You need to hire a company to direct the implementation process and still the project might be painful, and customisation costly and time-consuming. Not only does a company need an IT staff to handle patches, security and required system upgrades, it often has to pay the vendor or a third-party service provider for its expertise.
- Data. When moving to a new ERP, you may need to convert some data into a format that’s compatible with the new platform. This can lead to unexpected costs and delays, so review your databases, and work with your IT team or an integration partner to identify potential data compatibility issues early on.
- Flexibility. To fully use any ERP software you must feed it a lot of data. That can jeopardize the flexibility, especially in a small company. Unless you enter every single detail into the system, it won’t allow you to make any quick adjustments. So you might feel limited by that.
- Doesn’t solve process and policy issues: If you have error-prone or inefficient processes, an ERP won’t necessarily fix them, even though it may increase accuracy. The same goes for policies that hold the organization back — it’s up to you to adjust those and then configure the system to support better ways of doing business.
- Company culture. You should remember that an ERP system is not just a pure software package to be tailored to an organisation, but an organizational infrastructure that affects how people work. It is as if it imposes its own logic on a company’s strategy, organisation, and culture.
The point is that ERP systems are not the evil of this world, and we criticize them just as competitive solutions. Many companies may benefit from implementing an ERP system, just not a small manufacturing business.
Is an ERP a smart choice for a small manufacturing company?
Suppose you are an owner of a fast-growing manufacturing business you want to keep up with the company needs. You picture yourself as a successful businessman thriving over rivals, leading your manufacturing company into changes and the digital revolution. As a manager, you wish to be like a magician performing in front of the cheering crowd of spectators. The wizard pulls stunt after stunt, and the audience admires his dexterity and mastery. He expertly deals cards in the centre of the stage, and although you don’t believe in magic, nonetheless, feel charmed by his performance. When you think it’s the end of the show, he still manages to surprise you with having an ace upon his sleeve and gathers a round of applause.
You might ask, what’s this got to do with production scheduling and the choice of online software? Managing manufacture is a serious business, after all, not just tricks and fun. Well, let me explain the analogy and show you that having the upper hand proves very practical, in both cases: magician’s performance and surpassing your manufacturing rivals. Thanks to easy-to-use online management software, you can take the centre of the stage and deal with all the cards. How is that possible? Read on.
Once you’ve got a good grasp of what ERP is, it makes sense to discover different ways to help your business stay organized — optimizing your costs and operations to help you make data-driven decisions that improve your business performance.
ULTIMATE GUIDE WHICH HELPS YOU TO CHOOSE MANUFACTURING SCHEDULING SOFTWARE.
Choosing the right system
For the majority of small manufacturing companies the decision of choosing the right software is very important. Moving from chaos, paper notebooks, and little or almost none traceability / working time management into a paperless, digitized environment is a huge step.
On the other hand midsize organizations lack large IT teams, sophisticated equipment, big implementation budgets.To lower expenses of digital revolution they search for user-friendly, inexpensive solutions designed for a company that has limited technical expertise.
No matter what size is the company, owners and managers are generally focused on outcomes — using the information to achieve objectives, like increasing efficiency, reducing costs and responding to changing consumer needs or market conditions.
Purchasing manufacturing software is a big decision, so take the time to thoroughly evaluate all options.
Why is the ERP system not the best idea in a small manufacturing company?
Theoretically speaking, ERP systems are for manufacturers a dream come true. That’s why you might be surprised to learn that most implementations end up in disappointment, where a small company spends thousands of dollars on investment and returns to Excel or other simple solutions, such as Prodio.
The most important difference is that a small manufacturer assumes the system will automatically guess what they need, but unfortunately, it doesn’t work like that. Advanced ERP systems are incredible technological and mathematical creations. This allows them to automate technological processes in large factories where thousands of elements are produced. When there are thousands of orders at the production line every day, and a man can’t monitor them, all ERP systems thrive. They make sure the right parts are at the right place, at the right time—pure magic. ERP needs data regarding the present situation, the number of employees at the shop floor, their holiday schedule, production line status, and the queue of tasks for 2-3 months upfront. Only having completed these conditions you can plan production.
You can take the best, worth a couple of million ERP systems with artificial intelligence, but there is no way it would work in a small manufacturing company.
Why is ERP a bad idea?
- Flexibility and custom production: in a small manufacturing business, there isn’t time for the team to spend 1 hour on entering all data into the system, dividing the product into smaller parts, logistic minimum, surplus material, or material loss. The Client places an order, and its due date is “for yesterday,” which means all these preparatory jobs have to be skipped, and the system lacks operational data from the start.
- Imprecise data: in a small company, nobody cares about the % of losses, creating alternative technology, additional stock/ inventory, or schedules of machine downtime, not to mention even more advanced data.
- Mistakes copied from the production panels create chaos in the whole system Let’s assume that an employee makes a typo writing ex. 10 pieces instead of 100, or they click the wrong product. ERP systems count automatically and take away the given number of items from the stock, which works like a domino effect and spurs even more incorrect decisions.
- Sometimes there is a need to pass-by the system due to its inflexibility. A good ERP system won’t let you send an order to production when there isn’t a suitable raw material entered or technology, even though you know that this material is available and the technology could be completed on the go – well, that’s the trouble with using ERP.
Many years of experience have proved that most companies that implement Prodio want something which would make their life easier. They work not only with ERP but also with Excel. Why? If you can’t trust everything you have in your ERP system, there has to be somewhere else where you store your data safely, so naturally, you put your trust in Excel.
The alternative – simple manufacturing software
Manufacturing software can automate many error-prone tasks, like order processing, and provide the information teams need to operate more efficiently. When you run a small or mid-size company, you look for certain features that help you organize and manage workflow more efficiently.
You wish to:
- Organize your production by regaining control and learning about real cost and productivity,
- Identify patterns and flagging anomalies that require investigation.
- Provide fast communication between the manager and shop floor, clear vision of working schedule and parameters.
- Secure quick effects, functionality, simplicity (reducing functions that aren’t necessary).
Simple manufacturing software such as Prodio helps you organize and manage your orders so your team can work faster and smarter. Anticipate off times, vacations, sales reservations and get accurate availability information.
Other upsides include:
- Access to data from anywhere: Employees no longer need to shuffle through piles of papers or files scattered across a desktop. With cloud-based manufacturing software, a warehouse manager can log in from a mobile device while on the shop floor, or a salesperson can check inventory while at a customer site.
- Information is always up-to-date: Because the system is continually receiving information from various sources, it’s updated immediately. This provides a major advantage because decision-makers are basing their choices on up-to-the-minute data.
- Business decisions based on the same data: With a common database, all decision-makers are on the same page. There are no duplicate or conflicting sources of information, and companies have the ability to schedule and distribute dynamic reports automatically.
- Communication and cooperation: Simple online software knocks down walls between departments by giving employees appropriate access to data on related business functions. The communication flow is easy, and that results in fewer mistakes, increases transparency and minimizes complaints.
An ERP is a critical business system that must mesh with how each company operates, so there is no one “best” platform. Required capabilities, preferred deployment model and company size will all affect your decision when choosing a production management system.
It is a good idea to start with something simple and build from there. Mid-size companies often begin with a Prodio manufacturing software to automate basic accounting tasks and allow managers to easily view the flow of money into and out of the organization. Products-based companies typically want to digitize inventory and order management right away as well as they want to simplify employee time and resource tracking and project billing.
Purchasing and implementing manufacturing software can be intimidating, even overwhelming. But the solutions available today allow companies to take it one step at a time and add what they need when they need it. Never before has this been within reach for even the smallest companies, and it is good to take advantage of that.
Practical guide to help you choose the best production planning and production accounting software, and which will protect you from bad investments.